Excellent article on the rush to war by Arthur Schlesinger Jr.

I had been meaning to link to Today, It is We Americans Who Live in Infamy back on the 23rd of March when I first read it, but forgot to do so. A trip by Leoville reminded me of that intention.

NEW YORK—We are at war again—not because of enemy attack, as in World War II, nor because of incremental drift, as in the Vietnam War—but because of the deliberate and premeditated choice of our own government.

Now that we are embarked on this misadventure, let us hope that our intervention will be swift and decisive, and that victory will come with minimal American, British and civilian Iraqi casualties.

But let us continue to ask why our government chose to impose this war. The choice reflects a fatal turn in U.S. foreign policy, in which the strategic doctrine of containment and deterrence that led us to peaceful victory during the Cold War has been replaced by the Bush Doctrine of preventive war. The president has adopted a policy of “anticipatory self-defense” that is alarmingly similar to the policy that imperial Japan employed at Pearl Harbor on a date which, as an earlier American president said it would, lives in infamy.

Franklin D. Roosevelt was right, but today it is we Americans who live in infamy. The global wave of sympathy that engulfed the United States after 9/11 has given way to a global wave of hatred of American arrogance and militarism. Public opinion polls in friendly countries regard George W. Bush as a greater threat to peace than Saddam Hussein. Demonstrations around the planet, instead of denouncing the vicious rule of the Iraqi president, assail the United States on a daily basis.

I’m linking to it mainly because I’m still getting the occasional email from folks wondering what kind of commie-pinko I must be to question the justification for going to war with Iraq. Arthur Schlesinger Jr. manages in his essay to hit on every point of contention I have with this action by our government. You wanna know why I have a problem with this war? Go read his article and you’ll know why.

4 thoughts on “Excellent article on the rush to war by Arthur Schlesinger Jr.

  1. A wonderful post.

    I’m a UK citizen, but also a US Green Card holder, living in Texas.

    I oppose this war for several reasons, but the key reason is because the position of the US in the world, as the world’s fair and benevolent ‘uncle’ (although somewhat flawed) is grievously harmed.  As someone who moved to the US because I liked the ideals of the founding fathers and its constitution, as well as because my job moved over here, I have a passion for America.  But I feel that Bush and his right-wing pals have eroded the sympathy felt after 9/11, they’ve castrated the UN and have made the war on terrorism a more difficult war to win.

    Those concerned about America’s principles should have objected to the war – but unfortunately the unthinking cry of “my country, right or wrong” has won the day.

    The US will win against Iraq, but the war on terror will now be a more difficult proposition.

  2. I think that one of your countrymen (UK) said it best when he said:

    The best argument against democracy is a five-minute conversation with the average voter.
    Sir Winston Churchill

    That’s the rub; in our democratic process we have to give weight to the opinions of the uninformed and willfully ignorant

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.